Windows 8 first thoughts

I’ve been using Windows 8 for sometime now and I thought I’d put up a post touching on my initial love hate relationship with the new OS and why I can now see this OS for what it is and where I think it could fit into law firms.

I found in the end that the easiest way to understand Windows 8 is to understand the whole “Desktop” vs “App” thing, once you understand this it makes the perfect sense when to stay Windows 7, when to go Windows 8 and also the whole RT version vs the non RT versions on tablets becomes clear!

Lets start with the “desktop” world, easiest way to think of this is that every piece of software you currently have that runs in Windows 7 is the desktop world, it was all designed for the desktop. So Microsoft Word, Adobe Photoshop etc are all desktop software. Now Microsoft support this world in Windows 8, however the desktop is tucked away below the new tile start screen. You can pin a shortcut tile to this screen for Word, but launch it and it opens in that desktop space. So your desktop as you know it from the windows 7 world is effectively a layer below.

This is where my initial hate came from as I immediately tried to use “desktop” software. This does diminish over time as you get used to it, but read on. If you switch to the “App” world though the OS really does become a much more usable and enjoyable experience.
So Microsoft have created a new development platform in Windows 8, this is where the “Apps” come in. Adobe may create the next version of Photoshop as an “App”, you launch it the same way from a tile but this time it doesn’t switch into the desktop environment to run. It just runs the “App” basically like your iPad or iPhone does.

The “desktop” world still requires you to install the software in the same way, the “App” world though transitions the software into an AppStore. For now most of the Legal IT world has a bunch of desktop software and until such time that vendors start to build “App” versions of this software there is an argument to say stick with Windows 7. But this is the shift, it is effectively two separate environments and obviously your old software runs in the old “desktop” world. Over time though this will shift as more and more “Apps” become available.

So what about tablet versions. Well they’re easy to understand once you’ve understood the split. The RT release (which the surface runs) will just run the “Apps”, it won’t run the “Desktop” software. To run those you will need a tablet running the non RT version (this is what all laptops and desktop PCs will use). The version of office on the surface is an “App” version not the “Desktop” version, so Microsoft are pushing their own software down the “App” route. Why the split? Well the RT kit has different hardware “underneath the bonnet” and needs much less power, hence longer battery life (think iPad rather than laptop battery life).

Over time more suppliers will build “App” versions I’m sure and the need to run this desktop area will diminish. Microsoft have just been sensible in helping to manage the transition to the App world. For developers the great thing is the Windows 8 and the Windows Phone 8 platforms for “Apps” is closely tied meaning it will be fairly straightforward to make your App ready for the phone version once you’ve developed it for the desktop/tablet version.

Finally a slight aside for those thinking that the desktop environment will stay king and windows 8 will fail. This install of Windows 8 was installed on an old laptop, this first thing my 6 year old did when sat in front of it was to touch the tiles on the screen to try and start an app! We may be tethered to the mouse, but intuitively it’s not the right interface for the next generation.

Share

7 thoughts on “Windows 8 first thoughts”

  1. A colleague came up with a useful metaphor for the ’tiles’ screen at the start – think of it as a full-screen start menu that auto-opens. I changed my perspective immediately upon hearing it.

  2. There is nothing different with Windows 8 and Windows 7 once you use the start menu as you’re supposed to. From the beginning of Windows 7, Microsoft pushed search for the start menu. If you use search to launch your apps in Windows 7, you will have no issues in Windows 8. Stop using your mouse to launch applications in Windows 7! Push the start key on your keyboard, start typing powerpoint and press enter when powerpoint is highlighted. Your app has launched. You do the same in Windows 8. Just hit the start key and type the name of your app and hit enter. You’re done. Saying that Office on Windows RT is not the full version of Office is wrong. You can do anything in Word RT that you can do in the x86 version, with a few exceptions. Track changes, done. Compart documents, done. View the transitions in a powerpoint deck, done. Edit an excel spreadsheet, done.

  3. i have had a quite a few clients ask for this upgrade as the upgrade cost was £35. After showing them that it wasnt practical in the office it was dropped like a brick. Its the same microsoft issue, always skip the middle OS windows xp like, windows vista drop, windows 7 like!

    1. I’m not so sure Glenn, I wouldn’t advice corporates moving yet but I don’t think it’s a Vista. The “App” concept and the tablet form factor will offer enough to make people want to move.

  4. Thanks for this article and I’ve just upgraded my laptop to Windows 8. I have to say I like everything about it except for the tiles screen. It’s faster than Win 7 and the improvements to file explorer are good. However, I use the Win + D key to get straight to the desktop every time.

    The problem is, there are very few apps that cannot now be run in a browser. The only ones I can think of are:

    – Skype
    – iTunes / Media Player /Spotify
    – MS Office

    The last of these requires desktop mode anyway.

    So why would you use tiles when you can use Chrome which has a convenient tab system for multi tasking.

    Perhaps it works better on a touch screen…?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.